Introduction

PEEK-OPTIMA™ has been considered as an alternative to cobalt chrome in the femoral component of total knee replacements. Whole joint wear simulation studies of both the tibiofemoral and patellofemoral joints carried out to date have shown an equivalent wear rate of UHMWPE tibial and patella components against PEEK and cobalt chrome (CoCr) femoral components. In this study, the influence of third body wear on UHMWPE-on-PEEK was investigated, tests on UHMWPE-on-CoCr were carried out in parallel to compare PEEK to a conventional femoral component material.

Component alignment and soft tissue constraints are key factors affecting function and implant survival after total knee replacement (TKR). Knee kinematics contribute to knee function whilst soft tissue constraints and component alignment impact polyethylene wear. This study experimentally investigated the effect of soft tissue constraints and component alignment on the kinematics and wear of a TKR.

A six station electromechanical ProSim knee simulator was used with the ISO 14243-1:2009 standard force control inputs; axial force, flexion-extension (FE), tibial rotation (TR) torque and anterior-posterior (AP) force. This allowed the kinematics to vary with the test conditions. The soft tissue constraints were simulated using virtual springs.

DePuy Sigma XLK fixed bearing TKRs were tested in 25% bovine serum (in 0.04% sodium azide) lubricant. The average output kinematics across 6 stations were found for each test and the peak values compared. The wear rates were calculated over 2 million cycles (MC), the serum was changed every 350,000 cycles and the tibial inserts weighed after every MC. A one way ANOVA and post hoc Tukey's test was used to compare the kinematics and wear with significance taken at p<0.05.

The kinematics and wear rates for three soft tissue conditions were established under ideal alignment (Table 1). The ISO standard springs for a cruciate substituting (CS) and a cruciate retaining (CR) prosthesis were used to represent a knee with a resected ACL and PCL and a knee with a resected ACL respectively. The third spring condition was based on clinical data to represent a “stiff” knee.

Three other alignment conditions were then assessed using “stiff” knee springs; 4° varus, 14° rotational mismatch and 10° posterior tibial slope. These alignments were chosen to represent the range found in clinical data.

Under ideal alignment the “stiff” knee springs had significantly lower peak AP and TR displacements (0.9mm, 2mm, 2mm and 3.6°, 7.1°, 7.8° for the “stiff”, CR and CS springs respectively) than the other springs (p<0.01). The “stiff” knee spring had a significantly lower wear rate than the CR spring; 1.58 ±1.20mm³/MC compared to 4.71±1.29 mm³/MC (p<0.01).

The varus and rotated components had significantly larger peak AP displacements of 2.56mm and 2.42mm respectively, than the ideal and tibial slope fixtures (1.97mm and 0.92mm respectively) (p<0.01). The rotated components had significantly higher internal rotation of 12.2° compared to 4.4°, 3.7° and 3.5° for the tibial slope, varus and ideal components respectively (p<0.01).

The ideal and varus components had significantly lower wear than the tibial slope and rotated components (1.58±1.20mm³/MC and 0.15±0.83mm³/MC compared to 8.24±7.72mm³/MC and 5.19±1.12mm³/MC respectively) (p<0.01). This may be due to increased AP and TR displacements with the rotated components and the increased anterior AP displacement with the tibial slope components, resulting in wear on the posterior edge of the tibial insert.

Soft tissue constraints and component alignment had a significant effect on the kinematics and wear. Experimental simulation should test a variety of soft tissue and alignment conditions to reflect the range observed clinically and determine causes for early failure.

For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly.

Introduction

PEEK-OPTIMA™ has been considered as an alternative to cobalt chrome in the femoral component of total knee replacements. Wear simulation studies of both the tibiofemoral and patellofemoral joints carried out to date have shown an equivalent wear rate of UHMWPE tibial and patella components against PEEK and cobalt chrome (CoCr) femoral components implanted under optimal alignment conditions. In this study, fundamental pin-on-plate studies have been carried out to investigate the wear of UHMWPE-on-PEEK under a wider range of contact pressure and cross-shear conditions.

Introduction

The number of young and more active patients requiring total knee replacement (TKR) is increasing. Preclinical evaluation and understanding the long-term failure of TKR is therefore important. Preclinical wear simulation of TKR is usually performed according to the International Standards Organization (ISO) recommendations. Two international standards for preclinical wear simulation of TKRs have been developed so that the anterior-posterior (AP) translation and internal-external (IE) rotation can be driven in either force or displacement control. However, the effects of using different control regimes on the kinematics and wear of the same TKR have not been investigated. The current study investigated the kinematics, contact mechanics and wear performance of a TKR when running under ISO force and displacement control standards using an experimentally validated computational model.

Objectives

Bone void fillers are increasingly being used for dead space management in arthroplasty revision surgery. The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of calcium sulphate bone void filler (CS-BVF) on the damage and wear of total knee arthroplasty using experimental wear simulation.

Experimental simulation is the gold standard wear testing method for total knee replacements (TKR), with reliable replication of physiological kinematic conditions. When combined with a computational model, such a framework is able to offer deeper insight into the biomechanical and wear mechanisms. The current study developed and validated a comprehensive combined experimental and computational framework for pre-clinical biomechanics and wear simulation of TKR.

A six-station electro-mechanical knee simulator (SimSol, UK), capable of replicating highly demanding conditions with improved input kinematic following, was used to determine the wear of Sigma fixed bearing curved TKRs (DePuy, UK) under three different activities; standard-walking, deep-squat, and stairs-ascending. The computational model was used to predict the wear under these 3 conditions. The wear calculation was based on a modification of Archard's law which accounted for the effects of contact stress, contact area, sliding distance, and cross-shear on wear. The output wear predictions from the computational model were independently validated against the experimental wear rates.

The volumetric wear rates determined experimentally under standard-walking, deep-squat, and stairs-ascending conditions were 5.8±1.4, 3.5±0.8 and 7.1±2.0 [mm3/mc] respectively (mean ± 95% CI, n=6). The corresponding predicted wear rates were 4.5, 3.7, and 5.6 [mm3/mc]. The coefficient of determination for the wear prediction of the framework was 0.94.

The wear predictions from the computational model showed good agreement with the experimental wear rates. The model did not fully predict the changes found experimentally, indicating other factors in the experimental simulation not yet incorporated in the framework, such as plastic deformation, may play an additional role experimentally in high demand activities. This also emphasises the importance of the independent experimental validation of computational models.

The combined experimental and computational framework offered deeper insight into the contact mechanics and wear from three different standard and highly demanding daily activities. Future work will adopt the developed framework to predict the effects of patients and surgical factors on the mechanics and wear of TKR.

A pre-clinical experimental simulation model has been previously successfully developed, and was shown to have the potential for investigation of the biomechanical and tribological performance of early stage knee therapies. In order to investigate interventions that may necessitate sacrifice of the natural ligaments, it is necessary to replicate their function. This study investigated the most effective spring constraint conditions for the porcine knee model with the aim of replicating the natural ligament function.

The replication of natural ligament function was achieved through the use of physical springs in the anterior-posterior (AP) axis. Spring-9 (9 N/mm) and spring-20 (20 N/mm) were set at different free lengths in a natural knee simulator. The A/P displacement and shear force outputs from porcine knee samples (N=6) were measured and the most appropriate spring setting was determined by comparing the outputs at different spring settings with intact knee.

The A/P displacement of both spring-9 and spring-20 showed similar shapes to the all ligament control. Spring-9 with a free length of 4 mm and spring-20 with a free length of 5 mm showed minimal differences in A/P displacement output compared to the all ligament controls. There was no statistical difference between the two minimal differences either in A/P displacement or in shear force (paired t-test, p>0.05), which indicated that both conditions were appropriate spring constraint settings for the natural porcine knee model.

A porcine knee simulation model with refined spring constraint conditions was successfully developed in this study. Human knee model is currently under investigation using the methodology developed in porcine knee model, which will be more appropriate to investigate the effect of early stage knee therapies on the tribological function of the natural knee.

Ceramic-on-ceramic total hip replacements (THRs) have shown low wear volumes in standard gait hip simulator studies1. However clinical reports have indicated a variation in wear rates and formation of stripe wear on the ceramic femoral heads2. The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of different clinical conditions such as cup inclination angle and microseparation (head offset deficiency) on the wear of ceramic-on-ceramic THRs. The six station Leeds II hip joint simulator was used to investigate the wear of size 28mm ceramic-on-ceramic bearing couples. The alumina matrix composite ceramic material (AMC, Biolox Delta, CeramTec AG, Germany) was used in this study. The lubricant used was 25% bovine serum. The study was carried out for a total of five million cycles; the first two million cycles under standard gait conditions and a further three million cycles under microseparation conditions. During microseparation, a lateral movement of 0.5mm was applied to the cup relative to the head during the swing phase of the gait cycle3. Three of the cups were mounted to provide a clinical angle of 55°, which is referred to as the ‘standard’ condition; and the other three cups were mounted to provide a clinical angle of 65°, which is referred to as the ‘steep angle’ condition. These combinations provided four different testing conditions: standard, steep cup angle, microseparation, and combination of steep cup angle and microseparation conditions. Volumetric wear was determined gravimetrically and statistical analysis was performed using One Way ANOVA (significance at p< 0.05). Increasing the cup inclination angle from 55° to 65° had no significant effect on the wear rate in Biolox Delta ceramic-on-ceramic THRs under both standard (p> 0.42) and microseparation (p> 0.55) conditions. Under standard gait conditions, the mean wear rate for both cup inclination angles was very low at 0.05 mm3/million cycles. The introduction of microseparation to the standard gait cycle significantly increased the mean wear rates (p< 0.01) to 0.13 mm3/ million cycles for the ‘standard’ cup inclination angle of 55° and 0.11 mm3/million cycles for the ‘steep’ cup inclination angle of 65°. A stripe of wear on the head also formed, with corresponding superior rim wear on the cup. For comparison, the steady state wear rate of HIPed third generation alumina ceramic (Biolox Forte) under microseparation conditions was 1.3 mm3/million cycles [4]. In conclusion, increasing the cup inclination angle by 10° had no influence on the wear rate of Biolox Delta ceramic-on-ceramic bearings. The introduction of microseparation conditions significantly increased the wear rate and resulted in stripe-like wear on the femoral head, which has previously been observed on retrieved ceramic prosthesis. However, these wear rates were still low, and were ten times lower than those previously reported for Biolox Forte.

Introduction: There is increasing interest in the use of ceramic on ceramic bearings for hip replacement, due to recognition of their extremely low wear and biocompatibility of the wear debris [1].

The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of cup inclination angle and head position on the wear of ceramic-on-ceramic total hip replacements.

Methods: The wear of Biolox Delta alumina matrix composite ceramic (CeramTec AG, Germany) was investigated using the six station Leeds II Physiological Anatomical hip joint simulator, using 25% bovine serum as a lubricant. Three ceramic-on-ceramic bearings were mounted with the cup providing a clinical angle of 55o (representing the standard condition) and three were mounted to provide a clinical angle of 65o (representing the steep cup angle condition). Simulator studies were carried out under standard gait conditions for 2 million cycles, and under micro-separation conditions for a further 3 million cycles. Micro-separation and dynamic lateralisation of the position of the head replicate head/cup rim contact at heel strike and simulate stripe wear on a ceramic femoral head as found on ceramic-on-ceramic retrievals [2]. Volumetric wear was determined gravimetrically and statistical analysis was performed using One Way ANOVA.

Results: There was no difference in the wear rates under standard gait conditions for the standard and steep cup angles, with a wear rate of 0.05 mm3/million cycles. Under micro-separation conditions the wear rates increased significantly to 0.13 and 0.11 mm3/million cycles for the standard and steep cup angles respectively. However, there was no significant difference between the standard and steep cup angle groups.

Discussion: Micro-separation and dynamic lateralisation of the position of the head during gait simulation significantly increased wear. However, the inclination of the cup in ceramic-on-ceramic THRs did not have a significant effect on the wear under either standard gait or micro-separation conditions.

Introduction: There is increasing interest in the coupling of highly cross-linked polyethylene with large diameter heads in the hip. The aim of this study was to determine the wear of large (size 36 mm) highly cross-linked polyethylene inserts against ceramic and cobalt chrome femoral heads using a physiological hip simulator.

Methods: Size 36 mm Biolox® Forte alumina and cobalt chrome femoral heads were coupled with highly cross-linked polyethylene inserts in the ten station Leeds ProSim Physiological Anatomical Hip Joint Simulator. The simulator was run for 10 million cycles and the change in volume of the polyethylene inserts was determined geometrically.

Results: The volume change of the ceramic/cross-linked polyethylene bearing combinations during the first two million cycles of the hip simulator test was twice that of the cobalt chrome/cross-linked polyethylene bearing combinations due to increased creep. After 2 million cycles a steady state wear rate was reached. In contrast the cobalt chrome/cross-linked polyethylene bearing combinations reached their steady state at 1 million cycles.

The steady state wear rate for the ceramic/cross-linked polyethylene bearing combinations was 4.7 mm³/million cycles. This was a significant 40% reduction compared to the wear rate of the cobalt chrome/cross-linked polyethylene bearing combinations at 8.1 mm³/million cycles (p< 0.01).

Discussion: The clinical implications of this study relate to the measurement of in vivo wear, which is routinely assessed using penetration measured from radiographs. However, penetration is a measure of both wear and creep. This means that although the penetration of polyethylene inserts coupled with metal and ceramic femoral heads may be similar, the actual wear is likely to be lower with the ceramic heads due to their elevated creep

Considerable differences in kinematics between different designs of knee prostheses and compared to the natural knee have been seen in vivo. Most noticeably, lift off of the femoral condyles from the tibial insert has been observed in many patients. The aim of this study was to simulate lateral femoral condylar lift off in vitro and to compare the wear of fixed bearing knee prostheses with and without lift off.

Twelve PFC Sigma cruciate retaining fixed bearing knees (DePuy, Leeds, UK) were tested using six station simulators (Prosim, Manchester, UK). The kinematic input conditions were femoral axis loading (maximum 2.6 kN), flexion-extension (0–58°), internal/external rotation (±5°) and anterior/posterior displacement (0–5 mm). Six knees were tested under these standard conditions for 4 million cycles. Six knees were tested under these conditions with the addition of lateral femoral condylar lift off, for 5 million cycles. The lubricant used was 25% newborn calf serum. Wear of the inserts was determined gravimetrically.

Under the standard kinematic conditions the mean wear rate with 95% confidence limits was 8.8 ± 4.8 mm 3/million cycles. When femoral condylar lift off was simulated the mean wear rate increased to 16.4 ± 2.9mm 3/million cycles, which was statistically significantly higher (p < 0.01, Students t-test). The wear patterns on the femoral articulating surface of all the inserts showed more burnishing wear on the medial condyle than the lateral. However, in the simulation of lift off the medial condyle was more aggressively worn with evidence of adhesion and surface defects.

The presence of lateral femoral condylar lift off accelerated the wear of PFC Sigma cruciate retaining fixed bearing knees. The lateral lift off produced uneven loading of the bearing, resulting in elevated contact stresses and hence more wear damage to the medial side of the insert. The implications of condylar lift off include increased wear of the polyethylene and possible osteolysis.