The influence of Posterior Cruciate Ligament (PCL) removal and re-establishment of the posterior condylar recess on flexion and extension gaps width during posterior-stabilized Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) is still controversial. It has been reported that PCL resection lead to a selective increase of the flexion space of 3–4 mm, creating a potential for instability in flexion. Our hypothesis was that these surgical steps will equally increase both gaps. Measurements of the flexion and extension gaps heights were obtained during different surgical phases in 50 consecutive primary posterior-stabilised TKAs using a tensor device and a calibrated torque wrench. There was a slight symmetrical increase in both gaps after PCL release. In extension the width of the gap increased on average 1.3 mm and 1.0 mm in the medial and lateral compartment respectively. The same pattern was observed in flexion, averaging 1.3 mm medially and 1.3 mm laterally. Another increase of the two gaps was observed after the posterior condylar osteophytes were removed and the posterior recess was re-established. The gaps in extension increased, with respect to the baseline value, on average 1.8 mm medially and 1.8 mm laterally, while in flexion the increase averaged 2.0 mm and 2.2 respectively on the medial and lateral side. Again there were no statistical differences between flexion and extension gaps. No independent differences between the flexion and extension gaps were found in any considered surgical phase. PCL removal and re-establishment of posterior condylar recess does not seem to require any additional consideration in gap balancing during posterior-stabilized TKA.