The pathophysiology of high failure rates following rotator cuff tendon repairs, particularly massive tears, is not fully understood. Collagen structural changes have been shown to alter tendon thermal and mechanical properties. Thermal changes in small biopsies, detected by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) can help to quantify collagen structural differences in torn rotator cuff tendons. This study aimed to form a quantitative rather than qualitative assessment, of whether differences in collagen structure and integrity existed between small biopsies of normal, small and massive rotator cuff tears using DSC. Thermal properties were measured for 27 human biopsies taken intra-operatively from normal, small, and massive rotator cuff tendon tears. 3 samples were taken from each patient and subjected to a modulated temperature ramp between 20–80°C at a rate of 2°C per minute with 0.318°C amplitude. The melting temperature (TM) is proposed to represent amide-amide hydrogen bond breakage and resulting protein backbone mobility. Denaturing temperature (TD) reportedly corresponds to the temperature at which the proteins fall out of solution. Denaturation enthalpy (H) should correlate with the amount of triple helical structure. Based upon a pre-study power calculation, this study had 90% power to detect a 10% difference in melting and denaturation temperature between groups with alpha=0.05. 1 specimen per patients was also frozen and cryosectioned and polarised light microscopy was used for quantitative validation. The effect of tear size on heat related parameters were performed using a one-way ANOVA test. A student's unpaired t-test was used to search for differences between individual groups (small tears, massive tears and normal tendons).Introduction
Methods
High re-rupture rates following repairs of rotator cuff tears (RCTs) have resulted in the increased use of repair grafts to act as temporary scaffolds to support tendon healing. It has been estimated that thousands of extracellular matrix repair grafts are used annually to augment surgical repair of rotator cuff tears. The only mechanical assessment of the suitability of these grafts for rotator cuff repair has been made using tensile testing only, and compared grafts to canine infraspinatus. As the shoulder and rotator cuff tendons are exposed to shearing as well as uniaxial loading, we compared the response of repair grafts and human rotator cuff tendons to shearing mechanical stress. We used a novel technique to study material deformation, dynamic shear analysis (DSA). The shear properties of four RCT repair grafts were measured (Restore, GraftJacket, Zimmer Collagen Repair and SportsMesh). 3mm-sized biopsy samples were taken and subjected to DSA using oscillatory deformation under compression to calculate the storage modulus (G') as an indicator of mechanical integrity. To assess how well the repair grafts were matched to normal rotator cuff tendons, the storage modulus was calculated for 18 human rotator cuff specimens which were obtained from patients aged between 22 and 89 years (mean age 58.8 years, with 9 males and 9 females). Control human rotator cuff tendons were obtained from the edge of tendons during hemiarthoplasties and stabilisations. A 1-way ANOVA of all of the groups was performed to compare shear properties between the different commercially available repair grafts and human rotator cuff tendons to see if they were different. Specific comparison between the different repair grafts and normal rotator cuff tendons was done using a Dunn's multiple comparison test.Background
Methods
Improved understanding of the biomechanics and biology of rotator cuff tendons (RCT) may help reduce high re-rupture rates following repairs, particularly amongst larger tears. This study aims to use novel methods for quantitatively determining differences in the mechanical and thermal properties of intact healthy RCTs compared to torn ‘diseased’ tendons. A common problem in the mechanical testing of small tendon samples is that stress risers at the clamp-tendon interface can obscure measurements. As the shoulder is subject to shear, tension and compression, we developed a novel solution using Dynamic Shear Analysis (DSA), a form of rheology which studies material deformation. As collagen is the main component of RCT, the structure and mechanical properties may be affected by collagen conformational changes. Both dermis and rat tail tendon with increased collagen cross-linking exhibit stronger mechanical properties. Thermal changes detected by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) can help to quantify collagen structural differences in torn RCT, and has been previously used to study muscle, cartilage and vertebral discs. There were 79 tears (mean age 65.2 years), which were classified according to the size of the tear as small, medium, large and massive. Two separate 3mm-sized biopsy samples were taken and subjected to DSA using oscillatory deformation under compression. The storage modulus (G') was calculated and used as an indicator of mechanical integrity. 18 control tendon specimens were obtained from patients aged between 22-89 years (mean age 58.8 years) during shoulder hemiarthroplasties and stabilisations. Additionally 7 normal, 7 small and 7 massive frozen specimens were thermally characterized. 3 samples per patient were heated between 20-80oC in hermetically sealed vessels. Useful thermal parameters were measured such as the melting temperature (TM) which apparently represents breaking of the amide-amide bonds and protein chains mobility, the denaturation temperature (TD) which supposedly corresponds to proteins falling out of solution and the denaturation enthalpy (ΔH) which reflects the relative amount of triple helical structure. Healthy tendons had a significantly higher modulus than torn tendons, indicating that torn tendons are mechanically weaker than normal tendons (p = 0.032). Normal tendons had significantly higher mean shear modulus than tendons with small and massive tears (p<0.01). Overall there was a negative correlation between moduli and severity of tendon tear (r = −0.698, p=0.189). The moduli did not significantly correlate with age, sex, hand dominance, or length of preservation in formalin. Massive RCT tears had significantly higher TM and TD when compared to normal RCT (p < 0.05), unlike small RCT tears. No significant difference was detected between the denaturation enthalpy of the different RCT groups. This case control study has demonstrated that normal RCTs have a significantly higher modulus than torn tendons, indicating that torn tendons have less mechanical integrity. Our study further demonstrated a trend between increasing tear size and decreasing mechanical integrity. This study has also demonstrated differences in some of the thermal properties of normal and torn RCTs. These are likely due to collagen structural changes. A decrease in the denaturation temperature of torn tendons, suggests that the material is intrinsically less stable. Torn tendons with reduced storage modulus and collagen integrity may be less able to withstand mechanical loads following repair. This pilot study provides some preliminary insight into the mechanisms that may contribute to, or represent adaptations to high rates of failure of RCT repairs.
