This study evaluates patient reported outcome measurement information system (PROMIS) scores after total hip arthroplasty (THA) and total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) in matched cohorts, while simultaneously evaluating implant survivorship and 90-day hospital utilization. It is hypothesized that while both procedures would yield similar PROMIS score improvements, THA would demonstrate superior mid-term implant survivorship.

Primary THA and TAA patients from 2015–2022 with minimum one-year follow-up were retrospectively reviewed. After applying exclusion criteria, 2,092 THAs and 478 TAAs were included for analysis. Demographics, pre- and post-operative patient reported outcome measures (PROMs), revision surgeries, ED visits, and re-admissions were collected. THA and TAA patients were then propensity score matched at 2:1 ratio for age, sex, race, BMI, ASA, and comorbidities, resulting in a final cohort of 844 THAs and 455 TAAs for comparison.

There were similar pre-operative PROMIS Pain Interference (PI) scores between THA and TAA, with both showing improvement at six weeks. However, THA patients exhibited lower PI scores at one year (53.0 versus 54.0; p=0.009). Pre-operative PROMIS Physical Function (PF) was worse in THA patients but showed greater improvement compared to TAA patients at both six weeks (p<0.001) and one year (p<0.001). Pre-operative PROMIS depression scores were similar and improved similarly in both groups. Joint-specific PROMs (HOOS for THA and FAAM for TAA) improved in both cohorts. THA demonstrated superior survivorship free of all-cause revision at five years compared to TAA (95% versus 77%; p<0.0001).

Patients undergoing THA or TAA experienced significant improvements in their general and joint-specific PROMs post-operatively. However, patients undergoing THA demonstrated higher PROMIS PI and PF scores at one-year when compared to TAA, as well as improved survivorship. Generic PRO instruments enable comparison of medical treatments in different anatomic sites to the patients overall health.