The aim of the study was to assess the mortality associated with a hip fracture at 5 years in a geriatric population, and to evaluate the influence of age, cognitive state, mobility and residential status on long term survival after hip fracture. This study forms part of a prospective audit of all patients with a hip fracture admitted to Queen's Medical Centre, Nottingham. Every patient has a detailed admission questionnaire completed including details of the injury, medical history, residence and mobility. All data is collected by independent audit personnel using a detailed proforma. Integration with the database of the Office for National Statistics ensured accurate mortality data for every patient in the study for at least 5 years. All patients admitted in a 2 year period were included and divided into two groups: group B (<80 yrs age, Abbreviated Mental Test score 7/10, admitted from own home, independently mobile) and group A (any patient who did not fulfil all of group B criteria). A multivariate analysis indicated these as important variables that predicted mortality. Exclusion criteria: pathological hip fracture or bilateral hip fractures. 1319 patients fitted the inclusion criteria. 1068 patients fulfilled criteria for group A, 251 patients for group B. Overall mortality was 71% at 5 years. The excess mortality for the first year was 43%. 151 patients (60%) of group B were still alive at 5 years in comparison with only 231 (22%) of group A. Increased survival was shown for each variable: independent mobility RR 2.34 (p<0.05), admitted from home RR 3.81 (p<0.05), age<80 years RR 3.95 (p<0.05) and AMT 7/10 RR 5.45 (p<0.05). These results facilitate early recognition of those patients with an increased chance of long-term survival that may be suitable for surgical treatment, such as total hip replacement, which have a good long-term outcome.
Controversy exists regarding the management of intra-articular fractures of the calcaneus. We present medium-term outcome data on 37 consecutive patients who underwent open reduction and internal fixation for comminuted intra-articular calcaneal fractures. Operations were performed by one surgeon, CRW, following CT assessment of the fracture. All procedures were performed using an extensile lateral approach and early physiotherapy was standard. Case notes were reviewed retrospectively between three months and five years post-operatively. Patients were also invited to attend a follow-up clinic where outcomes were assessed using the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society Hind Foot Score and were questioned regarding on-going problems, change in shoe size and return to work. Complete data is available for 16 patients, with additional information from other patients. Results show average AOFAS scores for type II fractures to be 59/100, type III to be 81/100 and 79/100 for type IV fractures. We have shown low rates of complications – one infection, three patients requiring a change in shoe size and an average return to work of seven months. We have shown good medium-term outcome results for the operative management of displaced intra-articular fractures and to answer our question, we believe we should be operating on them.
