Aims. Highly cross-linked polyethylene (HXLPE) greatly reduces wear in total hip arthroplasty, compared to conventional polyethylene (CPE). Cross-linking is commonly achieved by irradiation. This study aimed to compare the degree of cross-linking and in vitro wear rates across a cohort of retrieved and unused polyethylene cups/liners from various brands. Methods. Polyethylene acetabular cups/liners were collected at one centre from 1 April 2021 to 30 April 2022. The trans-vinylene index (TVI) and oxidation index (OI) were determined by Fourier-transform infrared spectrometry. Wear was measured using a pin-on-disk test. Results. A total of 47 specimens from ten brands were included. The TVI was independent of time in vivo. A linear correlation (R. 2. = 0.995) was observed between the old and current TVI standards, except for vitamin E-containing polyethylene. The absorbed irradiation dose calculated from the TVI corresponded to product specifications for all but two products. For one electron beam-irradiated HXLPE, a mean dose of 241% (SD 18%) of specifications was determined. For another, gamma-irradiated HXLPE, a mean 41% (SD 13%) of specifications was determined. Lower wear was observed for higher TVI. Conclusion. The TVI is a reliable measure of the absorbed irradiation dose and does not alter over time in vivo. The products of various brands differ by manufacturing details and consequently cross-linking characteristics. Absorption and penetration of electron radiation and gamma radiation differ, potentially leading to higher degrees of cross-linking for electron radiation. There is a non-linear, inverse correlation between TVI and in vitro wear. The wear resistance of the HXLPE with low TVI was reduced and more comparable to CPE. Cite this article: Bone Joint Res 2024;13(11):682–693

Introduction. The optimum UHMWPE orthopaedic implant bearing surface must balance wear, oxidation and fatigue resistance. Antioxidant polyethylene addresses free radicals, resulting from irradiation used in cross-linking, that could oxidize and potentially lead to fatigue damage under cycles of in vivo use. Assessing the effectiveness of antioxidant (AO) polyethylene compared to conventional gamma-sterilized or remelted highly cross-linked (HXL) polyethylene is necessary to set realistic expectations of the service lifetime of AO polyethylene in the knee. This study evaluates what short-term antioxidant UHMWPE retrievals can reveal about: (1) oxidation-resistance, and (2) fatigue-resistance of these new materials. Methods. An IRB-approved retrieval laboratory received 25 AO polyethylene tibial insert retrievals from three manufacturers with in vivo time of 0–3 years. These were compared with 20 conventional gamma-inert sterilized and 30 HXL (65-kGray, remelted) tibial inserts of the same in vivo duration range. The retrievals were. (1) analyzed for oxidation and trans-vinylene index (TVI) using an FTIR microscope, and (2) inserts of sufficient size and thickness were evaluated for mechanical properties by uniaxial tensile testing using an INSTRON load frame. Oxidation was reported as maximum oxidation measured in the scan from the articular surface to the backside of each bearing. TVI was reported as the average of all scans for each material. Average ultimate tensile strength (UTS), ultimate elongation (UE), and toughness were the reported mechanical properties for each material. Results. Maximum oxidation values differed significantly across material types (p=0.018, Figure 1). No antioxidant retrieval exhibited a subsurface oxidation peak, in contrast to conventional gamma-sterilized (55%) and highly cross-linked (37%) retrievals that exhibited subsurface oxidation peaks over the same in vivo time (Figure 2). Trans-vinylene index (TVI) correlated positively with nominal irradiation dose (p<0.001). Mechanical properties varied by material, with tensile toughness correlating negatively with increasing TVI (p<0.001, Figure 3). Discussion. AO polyethylene was developed to address the problem of free radicals in polyethylene resulting from irradiation used in cross-linking or sterilization. Each manufacturer used a different antioxidant or method of supplying the antioxidant. However, all of the antioxidant materials appeared to be effective at minimizing oxidation over the in vivo period of this study. The antioxidant materials prevented in vivo oxidation more effectively than both conventional gamma-sterilized and remelted HXL polyethylene, at least over the in vivo period represented. The toughness, or ability of the material to resist fatigue damage, decreased with increasing irradiation cross-linking dose (increasing TVI). The AO polyethylenes evaluated in this study had lower toughness than conventional gamma-sterilized polyethylene, but they avoided the loss of toughness due to remelting. Clinical relevance. Antioxidant polyethylene tibial retrievals showed superior oxidation resistance to conventional gamma-inert and remelted HXL inserts. Material toughness varied with the irradiation dose used to produce the material. Comparison of antioxidant retrieval tensile properties can be used as a guide for clinicians in choosing appropriate materials for the applications represented by their patients

Introduction. In vivo, UHMWPE bearing surfaces are subject to wear and oxidation that can lead to bearing fatigue or fracture. A prior study in our laboratory of early antioxidant (AO) polyethylene retrievals, compared to gamma-sterilized and highly cross-linked (HXL) retrievals, showed them to be more effective at preventing in vivo oxidation. The current analysis expands that early study, addressing the effect of:. manufacturing-variables on as-manufactured UHMWPE;. in vivo time on these initial properties;. identifying important factors in selecting UHMWPE for the hip or knee. Methods. After our prior report, our IRB-approved retrieval laboratory received an additional 96 consecutive AO-retrievals (19 hips, 77 knees: in vivo time 0–6.7 years) of three currently-marketed AO-polyethylenes. These retrievals represented two different antioxidants (Vitamin E and Covernox) and two different delivery methods: blending-prior-to and diffusing-after irradiation cross-linking. Consecutive HXL acetabular and tibial inserts, received at retrieval, with in vivo time of 0–6.7 years (260 remelted, 170 annealed) were used for comparison with AO-retrievals. All retrievals were analyzed for oxidation and trans-vinylene index (TVI) using a Thermo-Scientific iN10 FTIR microscope. Mechanical properties were evaluated for 35 tibial inserts by uniaxial tensile testing using an INSTRON load frame. Cross-link density (n=289) was measured using a previously published gravimetric gel swell technique. Oxidation was reported as maximum ketone oxidation index (KOI) measured for each bearing. TVI was reported as the average of all scans for each material. Cross-link density and mechanical properties were evaluated as a function of both TVI and oxidation. Results. Minimal increase in oxidation was seen in these AO-retrievals, out to almost 7 years in vivo. In contrast, HXL-retrievals showed increasing KOI with time in vivo (annealed-HXL = 0.127/year, remelted-HXL = 0.036/year, p<0.001). HXL oxidation rate was higher in knees (0.091/year) than in hips (0.048/year), p<0.001. Cross-link density (XLD) correlated positively with TVI for both HXL (Pearson's correlation=0.591, p<0.001) and AO (Pearson's correlation=0.598, p<0.001) retrievals. AO-materials had higher TVI for the same or similar XLD than did HXL polyethylene. XLD correlated negatively with KOI for HXL retrievals (Pearson's correlation=−0.447, p<0.001). Mechanical properties varied by material across all materials evaluated, with tensile toughness correlating negatively with increasing TVI (Pearson Correlation=−0.795, p<0.001). Discussion. Irradiation cross-linking has been used effectively to improve wear resistance. Residual free radicals from irradiation are the target of AO-polyethylene, to prevent loss of UHMWPE XLD, resulting from in vivo oxidation of free radicals as seen in HXL retrievals, and toughness, resulting from oxidation or initial remelting. Despite different manufacturing variables, AO-polyethylene retrievals in this cohort had minimal oxidation and no change in XLD or toughness due to oxidation. However, toughness did vary with irradiation dose as did cross-link density. To achieve the same level of cross-linking as HXL-polyethylene required a higher irradiation dose in blended AO-polyethylene. AO-polyethylenes evaluated in this study had toughness that decreased with irradiation dose, but avoided loss of toughness due to remelting. Because AO-polyethylenes did not oxidize, they did not show the decrease of cross-link density, and potential loss of wear resistance, seen in HXL-polyethylene. For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly

Introduction. While advances in joint-replacement technology have made total ankle arthroplasty a viable treatment for end-stage arthritis, revision rates for ankle replacements are higher than in hip or knee replacements [1]. The questions asked in this study were (1) what retrieved ankle devices demonstrate about ankle arthroplasty failures, and (2) how do these failures compare to those seen in the hip and the knee?. Materials and Methods. An IRB-approved retrieval laboratory received retrieved polyethylene inserts and surgeon-supplied reason for revision from 70 total-ankles (7 designs, including five currently-marketed designs) from 2002 to the present. All retrievals were rated for clinical damage. Polyethylene inserts received six months or less after retrieval (n=45) were analyzed for oxidation using Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, reported as maximum ketone oxidation index [2]. Insert sterilization method was verified using trans-vinylene index [3]. Oxidation measured in the 45 ankle inserts versus their time in vivo was compared to oxidation rates previously published for gamma-sterilized hip and knee polyethylene retrievals [6]. Statistical analysis was performed using IBM SPSS v.22. Results. The ankle devices were retrieved most commonly for loosening (n=22) followed by polyethylene fracture (n=9). These failure modes occurred after statistically different in vivo time (loosening: mean=4.4±3.6 years; polyethylene insert fracture: mean=9.5±4.1 years; p=0.002). Presence of clinical fatigue (cracking and/or delamination) was identified in 24 of the 70 retrieved inserts, and its presence correlated with in vivo time (Spearman's rho =0.449, p<0.001). Thirteen of these fatigued inserts were analyzed by FTIR. TVI analysis confirmed the sterilization method of the fatigued inserts: 12 gamma, 1 non-gamma sterilized. All 13 fatigued inserts had maximum ketone oxidation index (KOI) of 1.2 or higher. Presence of fatigue correlated with measured oxidation (Spearman's rho =0.685, p<0.001). Six of the 9 inserts that fractured in vivo were analyzed by FTIR. All were gamma-sterilized, and all had oxidation of 1.2 or higher. Oxidation rate determined for most of the 45 ankle inserts was at or above oxidation rates previously published for gamma-sterilized hip and knee polyethylene retrievals [6]. Discussion. This retrieval study concurs with the ankle arthroplasty literature that loosening is the most common reason for ankle revision [4]. Ankle inserts retrieved as a result of implant loosening had lower oxidation and no fatigue damage resulting from their shorter in vivo time. Fatigued and/or fractured inserts were in vivo for longer times, allowing more oxidation to occur. The effect of oxidation on polyethylene tensile strength and ductility has been reported for tibial inserts [5]. Oxidation above the critical value [5] has a dramatic effect on the ability of the polyethylene to resist fatigue damage and fracture, since the toughness of the polyethylene drops to near zero. All fatigued and fractured ankle inserts had oxidation that exceeded this critical oxidation. Most ankle inserts, whether gamma or non-gamma sterilized, oxidized at or above the oxidation rates previously published for gamma-sterilized hip and knee polyethylene retrievals [6]