Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 2 of 2
Results per page:
Applied filters
Content I can access

Include Proceedings
Dates
Year From

Year To

The ankle radiograph is a commonly requested investigation as the ankle joint is commonly injured. Each radiograph exposes 0.01 mSv of radiation to the patient that is equivalent to 1.5 days of natural background radiation [1]. The aim of the clinical audit was to use the Ottawa Ankle Rule to attempt to reduce the number of ankle radiographs taken in patients with acute ankle injuries and hence reduce the dose of ionising radiation the patient receives.

A retrospective audit was undertaken. 123 ankle radiograph requests and radiographs taken between May and July 2018 were evaluated. Each ankle radiograph request including patient history and clinical examination was graded against the Ottawa Ankle Rule. The rule states that 1 point(s) indicates radiograph series; (1) malleolar and/or midfoot pain; (1) tenderness over the posterior 6cm or tip of the lateral or medial malleolus (ankle); (1) tenderness over the navicular or the base of the fifth metatarsal (foot); (1) unable to take four steps both immediately and in the emergency department [2]. Patients who score 0 do not need radiograph series. Each radiograph was reviewed if a fracture was present or not.

The clinical audit identified 14 true positives where the Ottawa Ankle Rule scored 1 and the patient had an ankle fracture, and 2 false negatives (sensitivity 88%). There were 81 false positives, and 23 true negatives (specificity 22%). Therefore, a total of 23/123 ankle radiographs were unnecessary which is equivalent to 34.5 days of background radiation. The negative predictive value of the Ottawa Ankle Rule in this audit was 92%.

The low rate of Ottawa rule utilisation may unnecessarily cause patient harm that should be addressed. An educational intervention with physicians combined with integration of the Ottawa rule scoring in ankle radiograph requests is planned with re-audit in 6 months.


Aim

The knee radiograph is a commonly requested investigation as the knee joint is commonly injured. Each radiograph exposes 0.01mSv of radiation to the patient that is equivalent to 1.5 days of natural background radiation. Also, each knee radiograph costs approximately £37.16 to produce.

The aim of the clinical audit was to use the Pittsburgh knee rules to attempt to reduce the number of knee radiographs taken in patients with acute knee injuries and hence reduce the dose of ionising radiation the patient receives.

Method

A retrospective audit was undertaken. 149 knee requests and radiographs taken during October 2016 were evaluated. Each knee radiograph request including patient history and clinical examination was graded against the Pittsburgh knee rules to give a qualifying score. The Pittsburgh knee rules assigns 1 point for each of the following; blunt trauma or a fall, age less than 12 years or over 50 years, and unable to take 4 limping weight bearing steps in the emergency department. A Pittsburgh knee rule qualifying score warranting a knee radiograph is 2 or more points, where the patient must have had blunt trauma or a fall. A Pittsburgh knee rule score less than 2 points predicts a non-fractured knee and hence no radiograph warranted. Each radiograph was reviewed if a fracture was present or not.