Abstract
Introduction
We have compared the middle-term (average follow-up period; 10 years) clinical results of the K-MAX HS-3 tapered stem with those of the previous type having cylindrical tip.
Materials and Methods
In K-MAX HS-3 THA (Kyocera Medical, Kyoto, Japan), cemented titanium alloy stem and all polyethylene cemented socket are used. This stem has the double tapered symmetrical stem design, allowing the rotational stability and uniform stress distribution (Type T) (Fig. 1). The features of this stem are; 1. Vanadium-free high-strength titanium alloy (Ti-15Mo-5Zr-3Al), 2. Double-tapered design, 3. Smooth surface (Ra 0.4μm), 4. Broad proximal profile, 5. Small collar. In contrast, previous type stem, which was made of the same smooth-surface titanium alloy, has the design with cylindrical stem tip, allowing the maximum filling of the femoral canal (Type C) (Fig. 2). Osteolysis at the distal end of the stem had been reported in a few cases in Type C, probably due to the local stress concentration. Therefore the tapered stem was designed, expecting better clinical results.
All surgery was performed at Kitano Hospital between September 2003 and June 2006. 72 THA were performed (Type T; 52 hips, Type C; 20 hips). The average age of the patients at the operation was 61 and 69 years and the average follow-up period was 10.1 and 10.4 years for the Type T and C, respectively. The all-polyethylene socket was fixed by bone cement, and the femoral head material was alumina or CoCr (22 or 26 mm).
Results
One hip was revised in Type C. Japanese orthopaedic association (JOA) score improved from 39/37 to 84/77 points (Type T/C). Postoperative complication was dislocation in one case (Type C; 1). Socket loosening was not observed radiographically. Stem loosening was observed in one hip in Type C, demonstrating osteolysis at the distal end of the stem. In this case, revision THA was performed 3.5 years postoperatively. Bone resorption was more frequently observed in Type C than Type T. Cortical hypertrophy was observed in 7.7% in Type T and 25% in Type C.
Discussion
The middle-term clinical results of K-MAX HS-3 taper stem (Type T) was excellent. The osteolysis at the stem tip was not observed in this type, which was observed in a few cases in previous Type C. From the X-ray finding, it was suggested that Type T had more uniform stress distribution to the femoral bone than Type C. Moreover, the problems associated with titanium alloy usage were not observed.
From the present investigation, good long-term results of the tapered titanium stem (Type T) was expected.
For any figures or tables, please contact authors directly (see Info & Metrics tab above).
