PRECISION OF NAVIGATION IN ACETABULAR RECONSTRUCTION IN TOTAL HIP REPLACEMENT

Abstract

Introduction: Navigation increases the precision and reproducibility of reconstruction in THR. It is important for the surgeon to be able to trust the reproducibility of the navigator and that navigated surgery should produce better results than those obtained by the surgeon by himself. The aim of this study is to determine the reproducibility and trustworthiness of a navigation system for acetabular reconstruction and to compare the precision of the navigator with that of the surgeon.

Materials and methods: A total of 101 THRs were carried out in 99 patients using image-free navigation. The precision and reproducibility of the navigator were measured with 30 postoperative CT scans. The blind estimates of the surgeons for inclination and anteversion were compared to the values of the navigator; the navigator was as accurate as the surgeon in 101 cases.

Results: The precision of the navigator for inclination was 4.4° with a reproducibility of 0.03 and for ante-version it was 4.1° with a reproducibility of 0.73. The precision of experienced surgeons for inclination was 11.5° and 12.3° for anteversion (less experienced surgeons had a precision for inclination of 13.1° and for anteversion of 13.9°).

Conclusions: Computer accuracy for the real value of a CT scan is always within 5°. The estimations of the surgeons with mechanical guides, experience and good judgment are about 12 degrees that of the navigation system. However the percentage of values 5° higher than the desired levels in experienced surgeons is seen in about 30% of cases (in less experienced surgeons, in about 50%). The computer can eliminate acetabular malposition to within about 5 degrees for desired values and in this way improve stability and wear.