Abstract
Background: The most commonly used implant for the internal fixation of an extracapsular proximal femoral fracture is a sliding hip screw (SHS). More recently short intramedullary nails (IMN) have been advocated as an alternative, particularly for unstable fractures due to possible biomechanical advantages. The purpose of this meta-analysis was to compare, on the basis of evidence from randomised controlled trials, the fixation outcome with these two types of implant in stable and unstable fractures
Method: All randomised controlled studies comparing intramedullary nails with a SHS were considered for inclusion. Studies were identified using the search strategy of the Cochrane Collaboration, with no restriction on languages or source. Two authors independently extracted the data, and assessed trial methodology.
Results: 24 randomised trials involving 3202 patients with 3279 fractures were included in the analysis. Pooled results gave no statistically significant difference in the cut-out rate between the IMN or SHS 41/1556 and 37/1626 (Relative risk 1.19; 95% confidence interval 0.78 to 1.82). There was an increased total failure rate (103/1495 and 58/1565, Relative risk 1.83; 95% confidence interval 1.35 to 2.50) and re-operation rate (57/1357 and 35/1415, Relative risk 1.63; 95% confidence interval 1.11 to 2.40) with the IMN compared the SHS when all fractures were considered. Fracture healing complications were much less frequent for stable fractures. No evidence for a reduced failure rate for IMN’s in unstable fractures patterns could be found.
Conclusions: The results from studies to date indicate an increased fixation failure rate for trochanteric fractures fixed with an intramedullary nail, and show no benefit to the use of a nail in unstable fractures. Therefore the use of intramedullary nails for trochanteric fractures cannot be recommended.
Theses abstracts were prepared by Professor Roger Lemaire. Correspondence should be addressed to EFORT Central Office, Freihofstrasse 22, CH-8700 Küsnacht, Switzerland.