IMPACTION ALLOGRAFTING IN HIP REVISION SURGERY, TO GAMMA IRRADIATE OR NOT?

Abstract

Introduction Recent publications have confirmed that as many as one in four retrieved femoral heads can be significantly contaminated with potential pathogens. Reports from the Centre for Disease Control in Atlanta, Georgia have described fatal outcomes from the unwanted transmission of bacterial disease with inadequately processed allograft materials. Surgeons requesting non terminally sterilised bone refer to theoretical biological and biomechanical deleterious effects of gamma irradiation. This study examines the accuracy of those claims.

Methods We have investigated the effects of varying levels of gamma irradiation (0kG, 15kG and 25kG) on the biological competence of morsellised allograft bone and its associated biomechanical impaction qualities. The biological study has used an in vivo model (nude rat) to quantify the effects of gamma irradiation on osteoinduction and osteoconduction. An in vitro impaction routine has been used to measure compaction, impaction and stiffness in the allograft product.

Results There were no statistical differences in the biomechanical or biological properties of the 0kG and 15kG specimens (P< 0.05). Gamma irradiation at the 25kG level resulted in an allograft product of higher biomechanical stiffness, unchanged osteoinductivity and slightly lower osteoconductivity (P< 0.05).

Conclusion Terminal gamma irradiation of 15kG reduces the risk of bacterial transmission with allograft products. It does not alter the efficacy of the allograft at biological and biomechanical levels. Gamma irradiation represents the mainstay of sterilisation of musculoskeletal allograft materials. Australian practices appear to be leading an international trend.

In relation to the conduct of this study, one or more the authors have received, or are likely to receive direct material benefits.