Abstract
The displaced intracapsular fracture in the elderly has frequently been termed the ‘unsolved’ fracture because of the debate as whether the femoral head should be preserved or replaced. To answer this question 413 patients aged over 70 years with a displaced intracapsular fracture were entered into a prospective randomised trial, to treatment with either an uncemented Austin Moore hemiarthroplasty or reduction and fixation with three cancellous screws. Pathological fractures, Paget’s disease and rheumatoid arthritis patients were excluded. Analysis of pre-operative characteristics of patients showed there was no significant difference between the two groups. Mean follow-up of surviving patients was 827 days.
Internal fixation resulted in a reduced mean operative time (22 versus 47 minutes), operative blood loss (23ml versus 171mls) and transfusion requirements. There was no significant differences in the incidence of post-operative complications between treatment other than and increased risk of wound sepsis for arthroplasty (4/207 versus 0/206 deep wound infections). There was a consistent tendency to a marginally lower mortality following internal fixation (15.5% versus 12.7% at 90 days).
Six patients in the arthroplasty group required revision, four for loosening, one for sepsis and one for fracture around the implant. Non-union occurred in 64(31%) of those treated by internal fixation. Most of these patients had conversion to arthroplasty. Other complications of internal fixation requiring secondary operations were avascular necrosis (4 cases), fracture below implant (1 cases) and removal for painful screw heads (7 cases). Functional assessment of the survivors at one year from injury showed no significant difference between the two groups for pain or change in mobility.
These results indicate that arthroplasty for displaced intracapsular fractures in the elderly is associated with a reduced re-operation rate but at the expense of a marginally increased mortality.
The abstracts were prepared by Mr Simon Donell. Correspondence should be addressed to him at the Department of Orthopaedics, Norfolk & Norwich Hospital, Level 4, Centre Block, Colney Lane, Norwich NR4 7UY, United Kingdom.
