ANKLE FRACTURES – FUNCTIONAL OUTCOMES AFTER TWO YEARS

Abstract

Introduction: Ankle fractures are the third most common fracture presenting at public hospitals in New Zealand. There have been few outcome studies following treatment of ankle fractures.

Aim: To identify the relationship between three types of ankle fractures and the functional and quality of life outcomes for patients two years after the injuries.

Methods: Seventy-four patients seen at Wellington Hospital with ankle fractures during 1998 were contacted for the study. Patients had been treated by open reduction and internal fixation, or by the application of a plaster cast with manipulation of the fracture being performed where necessary. Each patient completed an ankle specific Olerud and Molander questionnaire and an EQ5D Quality of Life Outcome measure. All x-rays were analysed and the fractures were classified using the Weber classification.

Results: There were 22 males and 52 females, 11% had Weber type A fractures, 67% had Weber type B, 18% Weber type C and 4% an isolated posterior malleolar fracture. Fifty-one patients underwent surgery. Patients who sustained Weber type A fractures generally recorded good to excellent OMA scores, while those with Weber Band C fractures produced significantly poor results. An analysis of the ankle visual analogue score versus the method of treatment showed that patients who underwent surgery judged their ankle to be less functional than the patients who had non-surgical interventions. The mechanism of injury also correlated with the end result, patients who had injured their ankles during sporting activities scored lower scores than those who had injured their ankles in simple falls. Patients requiring removal of an internal fixation device had a lower OMA score when compared with those who retained their fixation devices in situ.

Conclusions: This long-term out come study indicated that there was significant dysfunction following ankle fractures, with a surprising level of disability following Weber B and C fractures. The results of this study do not indicate better results in those patients who underwent surgery.