CYST OF THE ANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT OR SPONTANEOUS DEGENERATION? A RADIOCLINICAL AND PATHOLOGICAL ANALYSIS OF NINE CASES

Abstract

Purpose: Radiologists describe cysts of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) as a cystic formation of the cruciate tentorium. The estimated prevalence is 0.2 to 1.3% of patients explored by magnetic resonance imaging. The purpose of this study was to better define the clinical symptoms involved by comparing clinical, radiological and pathological findings.

Material and methods: Between February 1996 and April 2000, nine men underwent surgery of the anterior cruciate ligament for cysts. Mean age at surgery was 43 years (26) 54). None of the patients had a history of trauma and one patient had undergone medial meniscectomy 12 months earlier due to meniscosis. Pain had been present for six months to seven years and progressed slowly. It was very specifically related to hyperflexion. Five patients exhibited a moderate effusion and five had a painful joint line. The Lachmann was stiff. Single leg stance plain x-rays were normal. Magnetic resonance imaging demonstrated a poorly delimited heterogeneous destructured aspect of the ACL in seven patients. The suggested diagnosis was “partial tear of the ACL or old tear of the ACL”. A perfectly circumscribed cyst was revealed by the MRI in two cases, lying behind the ACL in the tentorium of the notch. The posterior cruciate ligament had a normal aspect in all cases.

Results: All patients underwent arthroscopy. The ACL was deorganised, widened and yellow in eight, with a yellow circumscribed nodule on the posterior aspect in one. An impingement between the ACL and the tentorium of the notch was observed in one case. Total synovectomy of the ACL sheath removing part of the ligamentous fibres was performed in eight cases. An isolated cyst was removed in one. Plasty of the notch was performed in one. Pathology reported degenerative dystrophic lesions in eight cases and haemopigmented villonodulary synovitis in one. All patients were reviewed at a mean follow-up of 14 months (8–48). Pain at hyperflexion had completely subsided and there was no hydrarthrosis. The Lachmann was stiff and symmetrical.

Conclusion: The term ACL cyst is probably inappropriate because we were unable to find true cystic formations but rather a spontaneous degenerative process. Synovectomy of the sheath gave good clinical results. MRI findings can be a diagnostic pitfall: a destructured aspect of the ACL without a context of trauma should suggest spontaneous degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament.